Blog

Curious how to handle tough personalities in training sessions? This blog reveals practical, evidence-based tactics for engaging Silent Observers and transforming Know-It-Alls into collaborative allies.

Drawing on insights from top trainers and essential reads, you’ll discover new group techniques, smart questioning, and ways to turn challenges into breakthroughs. If you want every voice heard and your sessions energised, don’t miss these proven strategies - read the full post for actionable inspiration!

New Tools for Tough Delegates

Every training session brings new personalities and new lessons. In this post, I’ll share how I learned, sometimes awkwardly, sometimes with a breakthrough, to handle two more challenging types: the Silent Observer and the Know-It-All.

Each required a different approach, drawing on both difficult and crucial conversations, as well as wisdom from world-class trainers and essential reading.

The Silent Observer: Drawing Out the Quiet Strength

At first, Silent Observers left me guessing. They rarely spoke, and I’d worry they were disengaged. My early attempts to call on them directly only made them shrink further. After reading Sharon Bowman’s “Training from the Back of the Room” and an article by Nancy Duarte on inclusive facilitation, I tried a new tactic: pair or triad work with written reflections. I also learned from the “Crucial Conversations” framework to ask open, low-pressure questions and to “make it safe” for all voices.

During one session, I divided the 21 people into seven groups of three, handed out Post-its and invited everyone to write their answer to my question before sharing with their two colleagues. Then I asked for one person in a triad to give me one of their three answers, before asking for the next triad for one of theirs. A different answer to what we had already heard. Once I had one completed one round of answers I went back round for more. Each time I asked for something different to what we had already heard. Soon all the different answers were exhausted. Now the Silent Observers were contributing with ease and often with brilliant insights that helped shape the rest of the conversations.

I now use this technique almost every session. Think. Write. Share – in pairs or threes, fours or fives. Because if you ask a question and invite an immediate response from anyone in the room the person that speaks first influences all the others. The speed and confidence of those that speak first can intimidate the “Silent Observer” particularly if they are speaking to the whole room. A pair is an easier conversation for more people. Beyond five and the size of the group can worry some “Silent Observers”

The “Think. Write. Share" process and the 3-5 group size combine to create multiple channels for participation, helping the quiet contributors while ensuring everyone gets airtime.

The Know-It-All: Turning Expertise into Collaboration

Know-It-Alls can dominate with facts and corrections. My first instinct in my early days as a trainer and facilitator was to challenge them, which sometimes escalated into a heated debate. After reading Gill Hasson’s “How to Deal with Difficult People” and a Harvard Business Review piece on managing strong personalities, I soon learnt how best to deal with this.

Gill recommends understanding the motivations behind each disruptive style because each are different. Their behaviour is often more about them than it is about us as the person at the front of the room. Recognising that can make it easier for us to manage our reactions. If we can remain calm and can avoid taking things personally, we can remain more solution focussed.

I shifted my approach to something more like judo rather than boxing. Instead of confronting and debating I respected and deflected their energy.

Crucial Conversations by Joseph Grenny and Kerry Patterson talks about “Asking the other person’s path” so I’d put the spotlight on them and say “Tell me more…?” and they would. Then I’d ask, “What led you there?” Or “How come?” Or “What experiences have led you to that understanding?”

After those extra two or three responses, I also made a point of acknowledging their expertise by saying “That’s a great insight, thanks for sharing.” before opening the floor. I’d floodlight the whole room with a sweep of my arm and ask, “Who else has experience with this?” or “What are some different perspectives?” This invited broader discussion and gently redirected the spotlight.

Over time, Know-It-Alls became valuable mentors for newer delegates, and the whole group benefited from their knowledge.

Reflection

Each challenging delegate has pushed me to grow, experiment, and seek out new strategies. By blending evidence-based frameworks with practical advice from top trainers, I’ve learned that the best results come from curiosity, empathy, and a willingness to try something new.

What’s your favourite way to draw out quiet voices or manage strong personalities in your sessions?